Re: Xmas Whiskies, Lancaster and Newcastle, Dec. 3rd and 12th
by Spirit of Islay » Sat Dec 13, 2008 7:39 pm
Last Night i went to the Last Whisky Lounge tasting of the Year in Newcastle , this one was all what Eddie Considered to be Christmas Style Whisky..... and Whiskey as it turned out.....
There was a smaller crowd than normal and all the Whisky was tasted blind .
With there been a smaller crowd the patter was flying about between us a lot more so normal notes weren't taken on my part . I did manage to keep up my good record though on blind guessing ( see Feis Ile Whisky nosing Competition.....) and failed miserably !
The first dram was at 43% and a pale Amber in colour , i didn't get a lot out it just a sweetness on the nose and Dark Treacle on the palate . Can't remember what i guessed this one as but i was way off .
My Score was 7 , the Groups 7.7
2nd up was at 40% and again a pale amber in colour , got a lot more out of this one , Light Christmas Cake , dried Smoke and slight Smoke on the nose . It had a touch Fishermans friends on the palate . I thought it was a Glen Scotia . 7.5 / 8.3
The Third dram was again at 43% , this one was a polished Gold in colour .
I got some strange ones from this , Scented Candles / Perfume on the nose , Parma Violets , perfumey and pepper on the palate . The nose and palate made me think Bowmore straight away .
7.5 / 8.1
Fourth of the night was my least favourite of the night , pure Amber in colour and at 50% , the nose wasn't too bad , Creamy Toffee and Treacle but the palate..... Struck matches ! With water it was even more sulphury !!
I thought it was a Linkwood , close but no cigar !
6.5 / 7.2
The penultimate dram was the weirdest of the night , a lovely Mahogany colour and at 47.8% , The nose was pure Christmas cake , dried fruit , spices , cake mix . The palate was Spices , wood and Polish . A really nice dram that had me guessing Bunnahabhain on the Nose , Japanese (Yamazaki) on the palate , how wrong was I !
8 / 7.9
Last up was my Favourite of the night , at 43% and a light Mahogany in colour , the nose was Burnt ashes (the fire the day after it's went out , iodine and smoke . Pretty much the same on the palate but with sweet sherry .
I guessed at Lagavulin .
8.5 / 8.8
So what were they ?
I'll tell you tomorrow.....
Just kidding !
1) Hibiki 17yo Blend
2) Kilbeggan 15yo
3) Macallan 30yo Fine Oak
4) Benromach Origins Batch 1
5) Van Winkle Family Reserve 13yo Rye
6) Lagavulin Distilers Edition 1991
Must say i was very surprised at No.3 and No.5 , especially when i was told how much No.3 was ! No.5 is worth further investigation......
So No good at Identifying whisky then.....
Cheers Eddie for another good night and till the next one !