tasty or yum-yum: Supernova or Uigedail ?

[100point]

What do you feel is more tasty or yum-yum Ardbeg Uigedail or Ardbeg Supernova? Comments?

[Ganga]

I much prefer the Uigeidail to the Nova. It's more subtle and has enough flavors to warrant some contemplation. Nova is a brash youngster.

[johan brugge]

I slightly prefer the Uigeadail, although I like the Supernova too. I just think the first one has more diversity in flavours. The Supernova's peat is so overwhelming that it blows you away.

[100point]

for the price it must be better Uigedail

[johan brugge]

for the price it must be better Uigedail

For me the price doesn't matter. The quality of the whisky on the contrary ...

[SoMK]

I way prefer Uigeadail to Supernova. The oogie is dense and subtle and full of flavours.. Supernova, although really nice, is for my taste way too young and "in your face". OOGIE !

[slojo]

Definitely the Uigeadail, absolutely no question.

IMHO of course

[100point]

Thanks bye bye

[borgom]

Uigeadail of course - JM says so..... unless of course Supernova gets a higher mark in the next bible.....

[Plastiquehomme]

I shan't vote as I have only tried Supernova. Admittedly I am no Ardbeg connoisseur, but of the 3 I have tried (Supernova, Renaissance and 10YO) I liked the Supernova best, then the 12 YO, then Renaissance. I simply don't have the disposable funds to buy a bottle of Uigeadail myself, but am trying to coerce a friend into believing its what he wants so I can try it.