Which would you choose?

[kiwicrusaders]

Which would you choose between these two, given they were the same price and why.

[pkt77242]

For me this is easy. The Uigeadail easily wins. The combo of sherry and peat torches the corry. The Uigeadail is also more complex to me and I find the Corry to be more of a one trick pony (don't het me wrong the Corry is enjoyable in its own right but can't compare in this case).

Sean

[johan brugge]

Sorry but I'm not going to vote. I struggled between the PE and the Brora already. I like both to much. It all depends on the mood I'm in.

[Willie JJ]

I preferred the Oogy to the original Corry. Not sure about the new Corry yet.

[andyt]

Definitely the Corry for me, it has a wonderful mouth feel and such a gorgeous taste. Just altogether more Ardbeggy.

[Ganga]

Oogie. Corry just doesn't strike me right although I found the General Release more enjoyable than the Committee Release. I much prefer the Beist to both.

[Drammed]

I enjoy the Corry more than the Uige. Not withstanding that I do not like sherry with my peat that much, the Corry has that extra kick and a hint of chocolate fudge to go with the underlying citrus that just gives it so much depth.

[talisker10]

Not going to vote since I have not had the Corry, but in reading various review and notes I am fairly sure I would prefer the Oogy. I love the mix of sherry and peat, sounds like the Corry is more of a peat and smoke blast..while I like that I prefer Laph for that.