I didn't vote for my favorite; I voted based on the topic which is bang for the buck. What really tips the scales in favor of Glenmorangie 10 is that I can get a 1.75 for $56 and sometimes Costco puts it on sale as well.
Ardbeg is probably the second one when I find it for around $45 follwed by HP 12 for around $40.
Laphroaig is suffering from growing pains. A year ago I was getting it for $30-33. Not worth the $45+ they want now.
Caol Ila is a 12 yo in these parts and runs quite a bit more than Ardbeg (closer to $60).
I believe Aberlour 12 (not seen the 10 in ages), Glenlivet 12, and Glenfiddich 12 are still good value.