I voted A'bunadh also as it is my favorite Sherry Monster. Having said that, I do find more of a difference in the batches than some people. The batch #13 was my least favorite and would probably fall behind the Macallan C/S. The batch #8 was as good as both the Mac and Glenfarclas, but the Batch #12 which I've had a couple bottles of, beats them all. An unopened batch #11 is still in the wings. I completely missed the batch #14 and have yet to purchase batch #15. To be fair, my Glenfarclas 105 was finished off back in January and my Macallan C/S was replaced but has sit unopened for nearly a year, so it's probably time to revisit. Veering slightly off topic I will say that Glenfarclas gets magical at 25yo while Mac and Aberlour don't suit me at higher ages, but not really a fair comparison, since my oldest Mac was 18 and Aberlour was 15.