Sure, some things are missing. I should choose Ardbeg if it was an option, (the other options I guess fit Ardbeg into a category), but that's because it made me fall in love with whisky and started me off in this crazy world. But if it's an island I'm stuck on, I assume it's also quite warm there. I would prefer something more summery like what I enjoyed last summer, the Bladnoch 12y Flora and Fauna. Manderines and cereal and fresh and excellent, probably perfect under a palm tree with a nice breeze.