inspired by the votes so far I decided to blind taste the AR and the AAT head-2-head.
Result: AR 3 - AAT 1
AAT won only in "nose in cask strength" where I find the AR missing everything. The AAT has a nice floral note and after a few minutes after that is gone there comes a bready-buttery note.
After adding water the AR wins all as IMHO water does the AAT no good.
The AR has a spicey-peppery-metallic start which is not as bold when diluted, but very pleasing even with lots of water.
I diluted both down to under 25% and the AAT is loosing more and more with adding water.
If I had to vote again I would vote for the AR now.