Sherried Malt wrote:Great idea for a thread, Ganga! Really handy way to get a sense of which bottlings went over well.
I assume you'll be posting these polls after every tasting now?
Someone, Matt maybe, did this for one of the previous tastings. I like the idea of favorite instead of best. Subjectivity is allowed free reign because people are allowed to use whatever factors they want-price, quality, etc-and proportion it out to come out with a personal favorite.
Yes, I think these will be very interesting to do each time. However, I'm not sure how to handle the a'bunadh as I believe that most of the batches from 6 through 23 will be brought to the table.
As for myself, I voted based on the Glenfiddich's I had Saturday which means I selected the Cask Strength. It just had that extra something at 51% that surpassed the others. I have had the 30 and plan to purchase a bottle in the near future as I think it is one of the better buys for a 30 yo OB. It has a lot to offer...at least for me.