Dubois wrote:One of my all-time favorites...
I'll simply echo the sentiments of Dubois and johan brugge by saying that the Lagavulin 12 Year Old, for me, is (to quote my tasting notes) "one of life's essentials".
Add water drop by drop (as you see fit) and I'm sure you'll revise your assessment of this wonderful whisky!
As a foot note (and for those of us who still recall the 1980s issues of standard 43%ABV strength 12YO Lagavulin), these recent cask-strength releases of the distillery's make represent something of a throwback to that monster of a malt.