by Paul A Jellis » Wed Apr 06, 2005 11:04 pm
There is a review of these by Dave Broom and Gavin Smith in Issue 39 of the Whisky magazine.
Dave Broom said:
Nose:
Pungent, intense, almost balsamic. Soot/wood embers, canvas, a hint of Arbroath smokie and grassy like a peat bank. Hairy chested.
Palate:
Rounded with good weight and depth. Seaweedy and lightly medicinal, hint of cattlecake. The firm centre is tempered by cooked orchard fruit.
Finish:
Sweet and slightly nutty. Smoke. Oatcake.
Comment:
A punchy, deep malt. Good balance.
and Gavin Smith said:
Nose:
Peat smoke, wet moss, scorched timber.
Palate:
Intense peat, seaweed, and dry, sooty oak. Cooked fruits struggling to come through.
Finish:
Long and smoky.
Comment:
Powerful, pungent malt with everything an Islay enthusiast would wish for.
The Wine and Liquor Depot website has them down as Lagavulin, as does whiskyworld.de - they even give the cask numbers.
I hope this helps.
Paul