I have a 1983/2001 PE from Scott’s. I think it’s very good, but it’s the only PE I’ve ever had so I can’t say how it compares to others. It’s similar to the Laphroaig c/s, but a touch more refined, still bold and smoky, but less medicinal (it also costs over a $100 more that the c/s Frogger
I have my eye on a 1988 Bunnahabhain from Scott’s that’s going for $120 and a 1974 Highland Park for $110. My only concern with Scott’s is that in my local area they are priced a fair amount above what most other IB’s sell for (when I can find them), which are more in the $50-$90 range. Based on on-line reviews I’ve seen, the consensus is that Scott’s puts out a consistently very good product, but doesn’t often venture into the realm of exceptional or superb.