All of those are good whiskies. The oldest of those is the 18yo and you can get it cheap here:
Personally, if it were a gift to me, out of those 4 that is the one I would be most thankful for (and I love Irish whiskey). It just seems the most special.
It really depends on how much you are willing to spend. If you want something special, but it has to be Jameson:
Jamesons 15 year old. Pure pot still (2000). This might cost you over £100 though. Also it is very powerfully flavoured and if your dad prefers the blend he may find it overpowering.
If you want any Irish, that is very very good. A lot Irish whiskey fans are raving about Redbreast 15yo:
http://www.thewhiskyexchange.com/acatal ... Y_139.html
For what it's worth I rate this as one of the best whiskies (top 5) I have tasted in my life (from any country).
Got a few hundred to spare ?
Knappogue Castle 1951