Had a sip of a 19 in a pub(yes!) the other night. It was amazing! Cherry, sherry, Sherbert, dusting sugar, cough linctus...but it could have been "tastier" due to the circumstances...warm vibes, great gig...warm whisky near the bottom of the bottle. i currently have the 16, newly opened, so hard to compare. Perhaps the 19 is a tad creamier??
whatever. i've never had a bad one...i've tried 13, 14, 15, 16, 19.