That's definitely a fair price too, it is $189 here.
So if you like Caol Ila, go for it, why not!!
It's $189MSRP here also, but the guy gets a special deal. I have gotten various other good bottles over the years, so... The hesitation with Caol Ila is, I liked the 12 and 18 OB's okay, but less than Ardbeg, Lagavulin, Laphroaig and Talisker. Also had a bad experience with a 1990 Signatory Caol Ila, all sulfur laden. I like the idea of a well aged cask strength Caol Ila. Is there something special that sets it apart? Any similarities to Talisker 25yo, which I enjoyed, and can replace for the same $$$, or two Uigeadail's or three Laga 16's or three Laph 10 C/S's. Decisions, decisions. Buy more of what I know I like or explore.
I guess I'm a little gun shy after getting a Balvenie 25yo Single Barrel recently and feeling it not really worth the 2.5 times the price of the 21yo Port Wood. That old law of diminishing returns, you know.