Tobermory 10 or Ledaig 10?

[Bulkington]

I want to get a bottle of one or the other. Recommendations?

[michael Foggarty]

Go for the Ledaig

I always get a bad rubber smell from the nose of Tobermory

[bamber]

I think Tobermory must be transported inside inner tubes. What is up with that stuff ?

[mikeymad]

Ledaig 10 almost everyday... I don't know what the difference of what Tobermory does to make the Ledaig vs. the standard Tob' 10. But I like the Ledaig better.

Cheers,

[Bulkington]

I went for the Ledaig before seeing these replies. Glad I did. It's good stuff. (And it seems like the Longrow CV bears more resemblance to it than to anything Islay.)

[Deactivated Member]

I want to get a bottle of one or the other. Recommendations?

Don't.

Oh, too late...well, I'm glad you're happy with your choice.

I think Tobermory must be transported inside inner tubes. What is up with that stuff ?

Inner tubes! You want inner tubes? Have you ever had a Littlemill? That one ruined my drams for the rest of the evening. Pints of Landlord could not wash the taste away. Big finish, you might say!

[bamber]

I've had a dram of a pretty old Littlemill at the SMWS and that is my only experience with the distillery. Was ok - nothing I'm sure like the legendary nastiness served up in their name at younger ages.

[Willie JJ]

Ledaig 10 almost everyday... I don't know what the difference of what Tobermory does to make the Ledaig vs. the standard Tob' 10. But I like the Ledaig better.

Cheers,

Ledaig has more peat which tends to mask revolting aromas and flavours.

[WhiskyViking]

I want to get a bottle of one or the other. Recommendations?

None. Get something good instead.

[Deactivated Member]

Get a quart of weedkiller instead of either. It may still cause you the same harm, but at least it will taste better!

[Bulkington]

Early results have found less venom in a bottle of Ledaig than in this thread....