Whisky Magazine

Issue 70 of Whisky Magazine out now!

Issue 70 Out Now

Read - Buy - Subscribe

Quick Links

Buy back issues
Cocktails
Distilleries
Find a whisky
Forums and chat
Independent bottlers
Magazine archive
News
Nosing & Tasting Course
Subscribe
Tasting notes
Whisky and food
Whisky Glossary



Search

Join Whiskymag.com Now
MAGAZINE
SUBSCRIBE
STORE
FEATURES
WHISKIES
DIRECTORY
FORUMS
This Issue (70)  |  Subscribe  |  Back Issues  |  Authors Index  |  Category Index
Categories Index   |  Whisky Debate

Articles in 'Whisky Debate'

Out of the box

There have been several high profile repackaging of famous brands recently. We are beginning to see
more attention paid to bottle shapes and presentation boxes. We decided to ask members of the
WhiskyMag.com what was catching their eye on the shelves and why.

Panel KW Keith Wood, Markt Schwaben,Germany KG Kenneth Graham Crieff, UK MM Michael Medve Emeryville, USA PM Pierre Mullin Fredericton, Canada Does packaging affect how the customer views a brand? KW: At the moment the whisky industry is enjoying a real boom period which is forecast to not on...

By Rob Allanson from Issue 63 published on 20/04/2007

Can the price be right?

In this issue we wanted to look act the effect of discounting. Who better qualified to pass comment
than drinkers themselves. So we put two questions to members of the WhiskyMag.com forum about how they view brands that had been discounted.

Panel Leonard Bacha Ohio, USA LB Michael Medve California, USA MM Sion Hannuna Bristol, USA SH Nick Brown Isle of Lewis, UK NB John Felber Ontario, Canada JF Q:Does discounting affect how the customer views a brand and its heritage? LB:Alot of it depends on the customer the brand is marketin...

By from Issue 62 published on 01/03/2007

The bourbon question

In this round table we asked two prominent members of the bourbon industry and Whisky Magazine readers about the future of bourbon.

Panel Chris Morris Woodford Reserve CM Julian Van Winkle Old Rip Van Winkle JW Jonathon Di Blasi Bergen, Norway JB Troy Egan Victoria, Australia TE Christopher Watkin Lincolnshire UK CW Q:How is the bourbon industry reaching new drinkers? CM:The bourbon category is doing two things, really....

By from Issue 61 published on 19/01/2007

The four Ps of presents

In this round table we ask how you make whisky the gift of choice over other luxury goods using price,positioning, promotion and packaging.

Panel Ian Bankier – The Whisky Shop IB Ken Grier – Malt director for the Edrington Group KG Larry Kass – Heaven Hill distilleries LK Jim Long – Chivas Bros. JL Robbie Millar – Compass Box RM IB: First, whisky needs to be available to the consumer on prime sites on the High Street and shopping...

By from Issue 60 published on 10/11/2006

The price is right?

In this issue we ask some of the industry’s luminaries to discuss the sensitive issue of pricing and effect on the public’s perception
of whisky.

Panel Iain Baxter – Inver House senior brand manager IB Ronnie Cox – The Glenrothes brand ambassador RC Ken Grier – Malt Director for the Edrington Group KG Dominic Roskrow – Whisky Magazine consultant Editor DR Ian Weir – Head of Marketing for Ian Macleod Distillers IW Q: Can premium malts ju...

By from Issue 59 published on 11/10/2006

Looking to the future

In this issue we look at how other spirits have far more flexibility to experiment and are therefore able to reinvent themselves to appeal to new drinkers,and ask is this damaging the future of whisky?

Panel Alex Turner, Woodford Reserve (AT) John Glaser, Compass Box (JG) Richard Paterson, Whyte and Mackay (RP) Q:Scotch whisky is bound by some pretty tough rules when it comes to production. Are these in essence right, or should there be scope for more flexibility? AT: As with all things con...

By Rob Allanson from Issue 58 published on 30/08/2006

The state of Japan

For this issue’s round table we hand over to Dave Broom, who recently hosted a live debate in Japan with representatives of three leading companies. This is his summary of that event

You probably know that the Japanese whisky industry is somewhat different to the Scottish. Given a business culture which is highly focused on loyalty to the company there is little chance of Japanese distillers exchanging stock, staff and information as their colleagues in Scotland do. This autono...

By Dave Broom from Issue 57 published on 21/07/2006

Stamp of authority

Tax stamps are being introduced for bottles of British spirits. In this issue we ask a panel whether they think they are a good idea

Panel Simon Coughlin, Bruichladdich (SC) John Glaser, Compass Box (JG) Euan Shand, Duncan Taylor (ES) David Williamson, Scotch Whisky Association (DW) Q. From a producer’s point of view are they a good thing or a bad thing? DW: International experience has been that tax stamps are ineffectiv...

By from Issue 56 published on 01/06/2006

View from the other side of the bar

In this issue we asked three people who stand against snobbery in whisky how they view the industry

The Participants: John Clotworthy (JC) Drumchork Lodge, Aultbea, Scotland Mike Hayward (MH) Nurse, malt collector and Whisky Magazine reader Dave Robertson (DR) John,Mark and Robbo’s Easy Drinking Whisky Company Q: Is the whisky trade doing enough to encourage new drinker...

By from Issue 55 published on 14/04/2006

All up for grabs?

Are premium bourbons better positioned to snap up new drinkers, or can Scotch and American whiskey both flourish side by side?

The Participants: Roy Evans (RE) Sazerac Jim Long (JL) Chivas Brothers Dave Broom (DB) Whisky Magazine Bill Samuels (BS) Maker’s Mark Q: A couple of bourbon companies have recently expressed the view that premium bourbon is on the edge of a major breakthrough because affluent upwardly mobile drin...

By from Issue 54 published on 03/03/2006

Tomorrow’s world

We recently teamed up with The Glenlivet for a readers’ evening to discuss the world of whisky. We asked them about the future

Chairman Dominic Roskrow, Editor, Whisky Magazine The participants Pieter Badenhorst (PB) Teacher,Waltham Cross, 29 Svat Buchlovsky (SB) Consultant, Basingstoke, 52 Brendon Humphreys (BH) Development manager, Loughton, 29 Ian Kendal (IK) Teacher, Loughton, Essex, 34 Barry King (BH) Retired, Chelten...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 53 published on 12/01/2006

Special finishing school

Whisky Magazine and The Glenlivet hosted a readers’ round table in London. In the first half we asked about wood finishes and innovations

Chairman Dominic Roskrow - Editor, Whisky Magazine The participants Pieter Badenhorst (PB) - Teacher,Waltham Cross Svat Buchlovsky (SB) - Consultant, Basingstoke Brendon Humphreys (BH) - Development manager, Loughton Ian Kendal (IK) - Teacher, Loughton, Essex Barry King (BH) - Retired, Cheltenham R...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 52 published on 30/11/2005

Are they coming to get us?

Smokers are facing ever increasing restrictions.Will the alcoholic drink sector be next?

The Panel James Leavey (JL) - Editor The FOREST Guides to Smoking in. London and Scotland. Dominic Roskrow (DR) - Editor Whisky Magazineand Cigar Buyer. David Williamson (DW) - Scotch Whisky Association. Q.Fears are growing that spirits and alcohol will follow tobacco and face first the threat of r...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 51 published on 07/10/2005

The name game

A spate of whiskies with strange names suggest whisky is moving forward in marketing terms. Is this a good thing? We asked a select panel of experts

The panel JG : John Glaser : Compass Box MR : Mark Reynier : Bruichladdich DR : Dave Robertson : Easy Drinking Whisky Company Q. In your view does the traditional whisky bottle label with age statement etc put some people off the product? JG: I think the traditional image that some people hav...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 49 published on 15/07/2005

All in the mix

Some whisky enthusiasts are naturally suspicious of whisky cocktails. But do they provide a platform from which to attract new whisky recruits?

The Panel Dale DeGroff - Renowned as The King of Cocktails (DDG) Dominic Roskrow - Editor of Whisky Magazine (DR) Audrey Saunders - New York mixologist and drinks consultant (AS) Q. Firstly, let’s get straight to the heart of the matter for Whisky Magazine readers. Are whisky cocktails good for the...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 48 published on 10/06/2005

What’s wrong with vat?

Inevitably this issue’s debate looks at labelling and the use of the words ‘blended malts’

The Panel Dave Broom, Contributing editor, Whisky Magazine (DB) John Glaser, Compass Box (JG) Martine Nouet, Regular Whisky Magazine contributor (MN) Erkin Touzmohamedov, Russian writer (ET) Ricky Christie, Speyside Distillery (RC) Q Are we winning the battle to get the consumer to understand the d...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 47 published on 05/04/2005

Treat us with respect

How should the industry react over the issue of responsible drinking?

The Panel Abigail Bosanko, author and whisky enthusiast (AB) Chuck Cowdrey, American whiskey writer (CKC) Keir Sword, proprietor, Royal Mile Whiskies (KS) Q. There is a growing view that society is becoming more litigious and governments are increasingly taking responsibility for society’s well bei...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 46 published on 10/3/2005

View from the other side

For this debate we ask a group of non whisky industry people for their view on the subject

Q. If someone mentions the word whisky to you, what thoughts immediately come to mind? JT: As someone who enjoys a fair amount in his spare time, my first thought would be one of delight. I can’t think of another spirit with as much obvious variety and diversity as whisky, provided you get past the...

By from Issue 45 published on 21/1/2005

That was the year that was

This month's round table looks back at the past year and looks forward to the year ahead

The Panel Ian Buxton, Whisky Magazine writer (IB) Chuck Cowdery, Whisky Magazine American correspondent (CKC) John Glaser, Compassbox (JG) Annabel Meikle, Scotch Malt Whisky Society (AM) Dave Robertson, Easy Drinking Whisky Company (DR) Q. Which sectors have done best, which have struggled, and...

By from Issue 44 published on 25/11/2004

It's all in the blend

This month we ask three master blenders where the sector fits in in respect to the rest of the whisky market

The Panel Jim Beveridge, technical specialist, whisky, for Diageo (JB) Richard Paterson, master blender for Whyte & Mackay (RP) John Ramsay, master blender for Edrington (JR) Colin Scott, master blender for Chivas Brothers (CS) Q. In your view, do blends receive the respect they deserve? JB: No...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 43 published on 23/10/2004

The times they are a changing

This month we ask a female only panel of whisky drinkers whether the image of malt whisky is changing

The Panel Gillian Bell, proprietor of online catering company Caledonian Connoisseur (GB) Abigail Bosanko, author and whisky enthusiast (AB) Annabel Meikle, Scotch Malt Whisky Society (AM) (Q) Whisky is seen primarily as a male drink. Is this changing? GB: In the main I think yes, but Scottish wom...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 42 published on 3/9/2004

Casting an eye to the future

This month’s debate looks at the future role of age statements on bourbons

The Panel Frank Coleman, Senior vice president for public relations, Distilleries Council of the United States (FC) Charles Cowdery, Whisky Magazine American correspondent (CKC) Dominic Roskrow, Whisky Magazine Editor (DR) Ken Weber, Global Brand Director, Buffalo Trace (KW) The debate: What’s the ...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 41 published on 16/7/2004

Are we good finishers?

In the latest of our round table debates, we look at special finishes.

The Panel Dave Broom, drinks guru (DB) Paul Godfrey, group marketing manager for malts, William Grant & Sons (PG) Bill Lumsden, Global brands ambassador/ master distiller, Glenmorangie (BL) Arthur Motley, Royal Mile Whiskies (AM) Keir Sword, Royal Mile Whiskies (KS) This issue’s question: Are speci...

By from Issue 40 published on 4/6/2004

Vat is the fuss about?

Are vatted malts set to be the success story of 2004? We asked a group of experts

Round table question: Vatted whisky is the way to attract new drinkers. Discuss The Panel Neil Macdonald, brand director, malt whiskies – Chivas Brothers (NMcD) Annabel Meikle, Scotch Malt Whisky Society (AM) Nick Morgan, marketing director for Classic Malts, Diageo (NM) Richard Paterson, master b...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 39 published on 1/5/2004

Young at heart?

In a new series we ask a panel of experts to debate a controversial subject

The Panel Dale DeGroff, International drinks consultant and writer Colum Egan, Master distiller, Bushmill’s Roy Evans, Sazerac David Stirk, Cadenhead Dr Barry Walsh, Chief blender, Irish Distillers This issue’s question: Are Irish and bourbon whiskey more likely to attract younger drinkers tha...

By Dominic Roskrow from Issue 38 published on 7/4/2004

A salt on the senses

Can you taste salt in whisky? Many say of course you can, but the suggestion incenses
others. Peter Woodsputs the case against

Scotch malt whisky has come a long way in the past 25 years, and not just in the all-important aspect of availability. Educated drinkers now have access to a wealth of words about the history, manufacture and appreciation of whisky. No other spirit can match it for sheer quantity and quality. Sadly ...

By Peter Woods from Issue 31 published on 9/6/2003