Dave Broom
Nose
Lurid colour. Toffee, nutella and cereal dryness to start, then becomes increasingly sulphury.
Palate
More tannic than you expect, the sulphur like a firework on the palate. Lacks elegance and balance.
Finish
Bitter.
Comment
“Sweet and sulphury”now, there’s a catchy brand name.
|
Martine Nouet
Nose
Sulphury, woody. Walnut stain. A hint of date. The sherry cask chokes the whisky.
Palate
Dry, sour, astringent. Oak juice, and not much more.
Finish
Of the same metal as we say in French! wood, wood, wood...
Comment
A good example of cask tyranny. The sherry acts like a tsunami. Makes no quarter!
|