Michael Jackson
Nose
Forest floor. Rooty. Sappy. Brown sugar.
Palate
Lightly creamy. Nutty. Slightly bitter.
Finish
Robust. Smoky. A hint of ash.
Comment
A big, robust whisky from the days when Glen Garioch made its own peated malt. I love the idea of a smoky whisky from the edge of Speyside, but I find this slightly astringent.
|
Dave Broom
Nose
Another with big cask influence-dunnage warehouse, varnish, black pepper, treacle, liquorice, dried fruits and smoke (smoked cheese?). A big boy.
Palate
Those big, rich, fruity, figgy, raisined flavours dominate, then comes a light perfumed note that just knocks the balance a bit.
Finish
Dry, smoky.
Comment
It has weight, it has style, but it just lacks balance.
|