Dave Broom
Nose
Light and grassy, then some Arbroath smokie. Lightly perfumed (sage, juniper?) with a vanilla lift, hot sand, ash-like smoke. Good balance and intensity. Needs water.
Palate
The sweetness continues. Light fruits, some creaminess. Quite firm without water.
Finish
Dry, long, lightly grassy. Ash.
Comment
Not instantly welcoming, this takes time to get to know...but it is worth the effort. Subtle complexities at work.
|
Arthur Motley
Nose
Lemon, tiger balm, eucalyptus, lime, citrus flavoured bathroom cleaner.
Palate
Some buttery character, but fairly woody and with a dirty smoke.
Finish
Ash.
Comment
Old, phenolic but just not pleasant enough for me. I think I just prefer Caol Ila young.
|