Not a member? - Register and login now.
All registered users can read our entire magazine archive.

WMI - Whisky Magazine Index

WMI 908.9 +11.0%

September 2014

September 2014 Whisky Auction preview

The autumn whisky auction season is shaping up well, with plenty of hot prospects to look forward to. There have been a few lots of whisky sold at Christies, London (Sept 11th), some high value vintage Macallan sold at Tennant’s (Sept 13th), with more whiskies to look forward to at Spink’s, Singapore (Sept 19th). The catalogues of the two major Scottish sales have now been published, so what gems do they have in store for us?

All six salesrooms will be in action simultaneously at Taylor’s Auctions in Montrose on Sept 20th, but saleroom 6 is the one you want for bidding on whisky. There are over 400 lots, with bargains galore to be had on vintage editions and old style whiskies. Standout lots for collectors include Lot 4153, a white label Cadenhead cask strength Glendronach 1970 58.9% (estimate £240-280), Lot 4019, a pre-Royal Warrant litre bottle of Laphroaig 10 Years Old (estimates £40-£60), Lot 4171, a black label Connoisseurs Choice Glenlossie 11 Years Old (estimate £250-300), a value pick of Lot 4133 Càrn Mòr Celebration of the Cask bottling of Bunnahabhain 23 Years Old (estimate £35-£45) plus lots of rooting about to enjoy for miniature collectors. There are some rather attractive White Horse Glen Elgin (lot 4007, 4041, 4064), a few ‘sunset’ era Highland Park bottlings (Lot 4045, 4073, 4146), and several Cadenhead dumpies (Lot 4009, 4031, 4077, 4107, 4215, 4344).

Mulberry Banks Auctions rescheduled their auction date to September 23rd and it all gets going at 10am. Look out for Lot 11, the Tullibardine 15 Years Old 1992 bottled for Whisky Magazine in 2007 for Whisky Live Glasgow with an estimate of £50-80. Lot 48 is the Springbank Millennium Collection with all six bottles and matching miniatures with an asking price of £4,500-6,500. This is the first set to appear at live auction since January this year, though that last set sold for £3,600. Will it reach Mulberry’s target? Relative to the retail prices of some new 50 year old whiskies, the six full sized bottles in the Collection still may offer very good value.

Elsewhere, there are a few familiar looking bottles of The Macallan that were unsold in auctions earlier in the year, further huge flagons of samples from Whyte & MacKay owned distilleries including The Dalmore, plenty of Manager’s Drams and Flora & Fauna editions, and some interesting vintage spirit discoveries. Some estimates look a little steep, such as the Highland Park Saint Magnus 12 year old with the estimate of £300-£360. These estimates may be set at the vendor’s insistence rather than the customers accepting the counsel of the auction house specialists, of course. Highland Park Earl Magnus 15 year old can make this price (as there were half as many bottles produced), but the Saint Magnus is regarded as a lower value edition. Out of interest, a quick check of Scotch Whisky Auctions, their Glasgow neighbours, finds that the best price they have sold a Saint Magnus for is £140. Finally, a great little curiosity is the Douglas Laing ceramic bottled in the mid-1980s as the official Halley’s Comet scotch whisky. Yours, for an estimated £50-70. Reach for the stars!

Top 25 Chart

Price Chg
1 Macallan +3.3%
2 Bowmore +1.7%
3 Karuizawa +2.8%
4 Ardbeg +1.3%
5 Springbank +3.6%
6 Glenmorangie +3.5%
7 Glenlivet +0.2%
8 Port Ellen +3.7%
9 Glenfiddich -2.4%
10 Highland Park +5.9%
11 Bruichladdich +0.7%
12 Caol Ila +7.2%
13 Dalmore +0.4%
14 Laphroaig +3.7%
15 Lagavulin +5.3%
16 Glenfarclas +4.7%
17 Talisker +5.3%
18 Rosebank -1.5%
19 Glen Grant +6.4%
20 Aberlour +0.9%
21 Balvenie +2.0%
22 Brora +5.0%
23 Van Winkle +0.0%
24 Mortlach +2.0%
25 Linkwood +0.0%

Brand Explorer

Beginners’ Guide

Read the Beginners’ Guide to WMI

Coming auctions

Tennants Auctioneers - 29th Nov
Fine Wine & Whisky


Karuizawa Overtakes Ardbeg
Jonny on auction watch

October 2014, Issue 123

Live Auctions Face Online Competition
Auction news with records broken

September 2014, Issue 122

A Future Number One
Karuizawa hits the high spots

July 2014, Issue 121

Online whisky record
Johnnie Walker 1805 bottle reaches £17,000

April 2014, Issue 119

The year that was 2013
We reflect on a year in the auction house

March 2014, Issue 118

Whisky gift and present finder