BECOME A MEMBER NEWSLETTER SIGN UP

Home >
Tastings >
Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection 1998, Claret Finish

Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection

Gordon & MacPhail Private Collection

Caol Ila Distillery

1998, Claret Finish

Private Collection

ABV: 40%

Age: No age statement Years Old

Style: Single Malt

Country: Scotland

Region: Islay

Bottling: Gordon & MacPhail

Overall
Score

7.5

Tasting Notes

Nose

Ripe fruit covers the peat but leaves the vanilla unscathed.

Palate

Unbelievably soft, with a hint of cherry.

Finish

No more than an echo of smoke and spice.

Comment

There are times when whiskies can be just a little too gentle....and this is one.

Taster Score

7.0

Tastings More from: Caol Ila Distillery

Caol Ila

Caol Ila

15 Years Old

Kingsbury's

Kingsbury's

23 Years Old

Adelphi

Adelphi

11 Years Old

Gordon & MacPhail

Gordon & MacPhail

1981

Murray McDavid

Murray McDavid

1989

Cadenhead's

Cadenhead's

9 Years Old

News

News Whisky Live Paris returns for 2026 — here's what you need to know

News America’s spirit, America’s story: Heaven Hill’s bet on bourbon

News The ‘Pearl of Speyside’ shines with core range Tormore launch

Caol Ila Distillery

From the Archive

News

Dram of Destiny targets two world records with actor James Cosmo on board: Organisers behind the Dram of Destiny event have announced their intention to break the world record for the largest in-person whisky tasting at a supper due to be held on Burns Night 2027   Image: Actor James Cosmo has joined the Dram of Destiny event as ambassador and master of ceremonies.

News

Inside The Dalmore's reimagined distillery and visitor experience: This is the fifth programme of expansion since the distillery was established in 1839

News

Farm-to-glass distillery Il Signor Camillo releases “entirely Italian” inaugural whisky: Il Signor Camillo has revealed its first whisky: an expression distilled entirely from spelt and already picking up accolades   Image: Il Signor Camillo's single grain whisky [Image courtesy of 1492 Coloniale Group]

News

Spirit of Speyside Whisky Festival celebrates record-breaking year: "There's nothing quite like it," festival chairman Henry Angus commented on the 2026 edition of the long-running whisky festival   Image: Inside Tormore's warehouse, which opened to the public for the festival [Image courtesy of Spirit of Speyside Whisky Festival]

News

Distillers eye £200m boost after Trump drops his whisky tariffs: Whisky lovers in America will be able to enjoy Scotch whisky again without paying an extra 10 per cent levy, writes Peter Ranscombe   Image: Nodjame Fouad, chief executive of the aged spirits unit at Pernod Ricard [Image courtesy of Pernod Ricard]

Latest Video

Free Whisky Content

Sign up for our newsletter and enjoy

access to insider stories, expert whisky reviews,

and exclusive partner offers.

First Name

Last Name

Email

Country

paragraph publishing ltd. Copyright © 2026 all rights reserved. Website by Acora One

Free Whisky Content

Sign up for our newsletter and enjoy

access to insider stories, expert whisky reviews,

and exclusive partner offers.

First Name

Last Name

Email

Country